Rolling Contact Bearing Vs Sliding Contact Bearing
Sliding Contact Bearing Vs Rolling Contact Bearing
Sliding Contact Bearing
1. High Starting friction due to metal to metal contact.
2. Difficult to achieve sub-micon positioning.
3. The life of sliding contact bearing is more.
4. Difficult to estimate rigidity.
5. Unsuitable for extremely low speed.
6. Good in taking shock load.
7. Required Continuous lubrication supply.
8. Suitable for high speed applications.
9. The relative motion between the contact surfaces is of sliding types.
10. Low running friction due to oil film separation the journal & bearing surfaces.
11. Suitable for high loads.
12. It take load only in one direction either radial or axial.
13. Sliding contact bearing have small radial dimension & large axial dimension for same load carrying capacity.
14. Sliding contact bearing required auxiliary equipments like pump, filter, sump, pipe lines etc.
15. In sliding contact bearing as there is no metal to metal contact, the operation is almost noiseless.
16. High initial cost.
17. High maintenance cost.
18. Sliding contact bearing are not available in standard size hence replacement is also difficult.
19. The design & manufacturing of journal bearing & housing is critical.
20. Sliding contact bearing have poor positional accuracy.
Rolling Contact Bearing
1. Low starting friction.
2. Easy to achieve sub-micon positioning.
3. The life of Rolling contact bearing is less due to fluctuating load.
4. Easy to estimate rigidity.
5. Suitable for extremely low speed.
6. Poor in taking shock load due to poor damping & metal to metal contact. Its subjected to plastic deformation under shock load & fatigue load.
7. Not required Continuous lubrication supply.
8. Not suitable for high speed applications.
9. The relative motion between the contact surfaces is of rolling types.
10. High running friction due to metal to metal contact.
11. Suitable for small or medium loads.
12. It take Combined radial & axial loads.
13. Rolling contact bearing have large radial dimension & small axial dimension for same load carrying capacity.
14. Rolling contact bearing don't required auxiliary equipments like pump, filter, sump, pipe lines etc.
15. In Rolling contact bearing as there is metal to metal contact, the operation is almost noisy.
16. Low initial cost.
17. Low maintenance cost.
18. Rolling contact bearing are available in standard size hence they selected from manufacturer's catalogue. The replacement of rolling contact bearing is easy.
19. The design & manufacturing of journal bearing & housing is not critical.
20. Rolling contact bearing have poor positional accuracy because inner race with respect to outer race is independent of operating parameters.
Comments
Post a Comment